Over the past six months, American Financial Group’s shares (currently trading at $126.21) have posted a disappointing 7.9% loss, well below the S&P 500’s 5.4% gain. This was partly due to its softer quarterly results and might have investors contemplating their next move.

Is now the time to buy American Financial Group, or should you be careful about including it in your portfolio? Get the full stock story straight from our expert analysts, it’s free.

Why Is American Financial Group Not Exciting?

Even with the cheaper entry price, we don't have much confidence in American Financial Group. Here are three reasons why you should be careful with AFG and a stock we'd rather own.

1. Net Premiums Earned Points to Soft Demand

Markets consistently prioritize net premiums earned growth over investment and fee income, recognizing its superior quality as a core indicator of the company’s underwriting success and market penetration.

American Financial Group’s net premiums earned has grown at a 6.6% annualized rate over the last two years, slightly worse than the broader insurance industry and in line with its total revenue.

2. EPS Barely Growing

We track the long-term change in earnings per share (EPS) because it highlights whether a company’s growth is profitable.

American Financial Group’s EPS grew at a weak 2.7% compounded annual growth rate over the last five years, lower than its 6.7% annualized revenue growth. This tells us the company became less profitable on a per-share basis as it expanded.

3. Substandard BVPS Growth Indicates Limited Asset Expansion

Book value per share (BVPS) serves as a key indicator of an insurer’s financial stability, reflecting a company’s ability to maintain adequate capital levels and meet its long-term obligations to policyholders.

To the detriment of investors, American Financial Group’s BVPS grew at a sluggish 6.5% annual clip over the last two years.

Final Judgment

American Financial Group isn’t a terrible business, but it isn’t one of our picks. After the recent drawdown, the stock trades at 2.2× forward P/B (or $126.21 per share). This valuation tells us a lot of optimism is priced in - we think there are better opportunities elsewhere. We’d recommend looking at one of Charlie Munger’s all-time favorite businesses.

Stocks We Would Buy Instead of American Financial Group

Trump’s April 2025 tariff bombshell triggered a massive market selloff, but stocks have since staged an impressive recovery, leaving those who panic sold on the sidelines.

Take advantage of the rebound by checking out our Top 6 Stocks for this week. This is a curated list of our High Quality stocks that have generated a market-beating return of 183% over the last five years (as of March 31st 2025).

Stocks that made our list in 2020 include now familiar names such as Nvidia (+1,545% between March 2020 and March 2025) as well as under-the-radar businesses like the once-micro-cap company Kadant (+351% five-year return). Find your next big winner with StockStory today.

StockStory is growing and hiring equity analyst and marketing roles. Are you a 0 to 1 builder passionate about the markets and AI? See the open roles here.