Oakland County probation violation lawyer Paul J. Tafelski (https://www.michigandefenselaw.com/etg-test-probation.html), of Michigan Defense Law, has shared critical insights regarding the reliability of ETG testing for individuals on probation for offenses such as Operating While Intoxicated (OWI). In the latest article, Tafelski discusses how these tests, despite being widely used in Michigan to monitor alcohol consumption during probation, may lead to unfair accusations and penalties.
ETG tests, also known as ethyl glucuronide tests, are frequently employed in Oakland County and across Michigan as a measure to verify if individuals have consumed alcohol within the probation period. Paul J. Tafelski explains that these tests are often used for OWI offenders to maintain compliance with abstinence requirements set by the court. However, Tafelski, an Oakland County probation violation lawyer, emphasizes that these tests are not as reliable as many believe, posing risks for those who might face unwarranted legal consequences.
"Although the ETG test is sensitive and widely adopted, it has been challenged for its accuracy. The U.S. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) has even declared it scientifically unsupportable when used as the sole basis for legal action," says Paul J. Tafelski. The Oakland County probation violation lawyer further explains that even incidental exposure to alcohol-containing household products such as hand sanitizers could trigger false positives. These false positives can create serious complications for those on probation, leading to accusations of violations that could potentially result in incarceration.
The ETG test detects alcohol consumption by measuring ethyl glucuronide levels in urine, indicating whether an individual has consumed alcohol in the past 80 hours. Initially, the test gained popularity in the early 2000s due to its sensitivity. It became a standard tool for law enforcement and probation officers to monitor individuals on probation for OWI offenses, such as those in Oakland County.
However, according to Tafelski, these tests may not provide accurate results, raising concerns about their use in probation cases. The probation violation lawyer outlines that even if an individual has not consumed alcohol, various common products such as mouthwash, colognes, or even certain medications could result in a false positive on the ETG test. This raises doubts about the test's credibility, especially when probation revocation or other legal consequences are at stake.
Paul J. Tafelski, as an Oakland County probation violation lawyer, advises that anyone accused based on an ETG test result should understand their rights. "Individuals accused of violating probation due to ETG test results have the right to challenge these results in a probation revocation hearing. It is crucial to question the reliability of the testing method and whether it accurately reflects alcohol consumption," Tafelski states.
When facing a probation violation charge in Oakland County, it is critical to mount a robust legal defense, particularly if the accusation is based on an ETG test result. The prosecutor or probation department must demonstrate that a violation likely occurred, although this burden of proof is not as stringent as in a criminal trial. An Oakland County probation violation lawyer such as Paul J. Tafelski can challenge the test results and cast doubt on the evidence, making it difficult for the prosecution to establish a violation convincingly.
SAMHSA’s 2006 advisory bulletin highlights that the ETG test is too sensitive and does not differentiate between alcohol ingested from beverages and alcohol exposure from other sources. Tafelski notes that understanding this is vital for building a defense. "Probationers must be aware that the ETG test, while used extensively, is not foolproof. Courts should not rely solely on these results to make punitive decisions. A knowledgeable probation violation attorney can introduce evidence questioning the validity of the test, making it harder for the prosecution to prove a violation conclusively," Tafelski adds.
Paul J. Tafelski strongly advises individuals who have been accused of violating probation based on an ETG test result to seek legal counsel immediately. "Before making any decisions or pleading guilty, it’s essential to consult with a skilled probation violation lawyer who can assess the specifics of your case and develop a defense strategy to protect your rights," Tafelski explains.
About Michigan Defense Law:
Michigan Defense Law, led by attorney Paul J. Tafelski, can provide legal defense services for individuals facing criminal charges, including OWI, probation violations, and other related matters in Oakland County and across Michigan. The firm is committed to offering comprehensive legal assistance to protect the rights of its clients, advocating for fair treatment and due process under the law.
Embeds:
Youtube Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aj6ZOcLAg3g
GMB: https://www.google.com/maps?cid=7441820969606749572
Email and website
Email: paul@michigandefenselaw.com
Website: https://www.michigandefenselaw.com/
Media Contact
Company Name: Michigan Defense Law
Contact Person: Paul J. Tafelski
Email: Send Email
Phone: (248) 451-2200
Address:2525 S Telegraph Rd suite 100
City: Bloomfield Hills
State: Michigan 48302
Country: United States
Website: https://www.michigandefenselaw.com/
